Ukraine War: How has the Internet Changed in Ukraine 12 Months on

Picture of Aftab Siddiqui
Senior Manager, Internet Technology - Asia-Pacific, Internet Society
Categories:
Twitter logo
LinkedIn logo
Facebook logo
February 23, 2023

It has been a year since Russian forces moved into Ukraine. Since then, Ukraine’s Internet connectivity has been affected by the ongoing war, particularly in the southern and eastern parts of the country where fighting has been heaviest.

Last year, Time covered in detail how Internet infrastructure is being targeted in Ukraine and how volunteers are helping restore the infrastructure wherever possible. The New York Times also published a piece on how Internet traffic from the Ukranian city of Kherson is being diverted through Russia.

We decided to look at what’s happened to Ukraine’s Internet using Internet number resource (IPv4, IPv6, and ASN) allocation data to see how things have changed from February 2022 to February 2023.

A Quick Overview of Internet Number Resources

The Internet is a collection of networks, nearly 77,000 to be precise. In general, every one of these networks autonomously maintains how the traffic flows within it and is called an Autonomous System (AS). To identify these networks — or ASes — across the global Internet, every network is assigned a unique number: an Autonomous System Number (ASN). Just as every network needs a unique number, every device connected to the Internet also requires a unique number, otherwise known as an Internet Protocol Address (IP address), either IPv4 or IPv6.

IPv4 and IPv6 address space and ASNs are collectively known as Internet number resources and are allocated by the five Regional Internet Registries (RIRs). Anyone operating a network can become a member of an RIR and request Internet number resources. Ukraine’s ASNs and IP address space are allocated and administered by the RIPE NCC, the RIR for Europe, the Middle East, and parts of Central Asia.

The Number Resource Organisation (NRO), the coordinating body for the five RIRs, makes all ASN, IPv4, and IPv6 address allocation data public via its daily delegation file.

ASNs

On 5 February 2022, the NRO delegation file suggests that there were 2,197 ASNs allocated to networks in Ukraine (Figure 1). As we can see, there has been a lot of movement over the past 12 months, which is not uncommon.

At one point, 2,199 ASNs were delegated to networks in Ukraine. The decline in the number of ASNs means that either the ASNs have been returned to the available pool by the networks in Ukraine or the holder of the ASN changed the country of origin from UA to something else.

Graph showing the number of ASNs delegated by RIPE NCC to networks in Ukraine since 5 January 2022.
Figure 1 — The number of ASNs delegated by RIPE NCC to networks in Ukraine (5 January 2022 to 5 February 2022). Note, this data only shows the number of ASNs that RIPE NCC assigned to networks in Ukraine. It doesn’t show that all of them were being used to route Internet traffic. Source: NRO.

In the last 12 months, more than 100 network registrations have moved out of Ukraine. More than 40 of these are now registered in Russia (Table 1).

24 February 202219 February 202324 February 202219 February 202324 February 202219 February 2023
UA 12959RU 12959UA 42301RU 42301UA 47379RU 47379
UA 196705RU 196705UA 42393RU 42393UA 47939RU 47939
UA 197129RU 197129UA 42394RU 42394UA 48711RU 48711
UA 197880RU 197880UA 42511RU 42511UA 49075RU 49075
UA 199908RU 199908UA 42518RU 42518UA 49536RU 49536
UA 21087RU 21087UA 42534RU 42534UA 49803RU 49803
UA 24758RU 24758UA 43564RU 43564UA 50210RU 50210
UA 29031RU 29031UA 43802RU 43802UA 51153RU 51153
UA 31387RU 31387UA 44240RU 44240UA 56676RU 56676
UA 41039RU 41039UA 44269RU 44269UA 57093RU 57093
UA 41082RU 41082UA 44584RU 44584UA 8381RU 8381
UA 41308RU 41308UA 44857RU 44857UA 8654RU 8654
UA 41479RU 41479UA 44878RU 44878
UA 41914RU 41914UA 47124RU 47124
UA 42104RU 42104UA 47243RU 47243
Table 1 — ASNs that were registered under Ukraine at the start of the war but, as of publishing, are registered in Russia.

Interestingly, the RIPE NCC transfer data shows that only the following five ASNs have been transferred in the last 12 months:

  • AS12959 Anton Bobrovnikov Teleradiocompany Nadezhda Ltd 13/09/2022 POLICY
  • AS210877 Towse’e Saman Information Technology Co. PJS TS Information Technology Limited 09/12/2022 POLICY
  • AS41039 Timer, LLC LLC “FTICOM” 30/09/2022 POLICY
  • AS44269 Informational-measuring systems Ltd. Electro-Communication Telecom Ltd 23/12/2022 POLICY
  • AS198654 PEKITEL Ltd. Ltd. Alfa Telecom 31/01/2017 POLICY AS48654 RTK-centr ltd. Balnet Ltd. 08/03/2022 POLICY

Why all of the 43 ASNs mentioned in the table above are not shown in the RIPE NCC transfer data is not clear to me. It could be due to the NWI-10 policy, which updated the country codes in delegated statistics: perhaps these networks changed their addresses from Ukraine to Russia.

Learn more about the RIPE NW1-10 policy and about its impact on the delegation statistics.

Table 2 shows which of the 100 moved or deregistered ASNs are now listed as Available or Reserved in the delegation file. These ASNs could be reassigned to other entities in the RIPE region.

24 February 202219 February 202324 February 202219 February 2023
UA 197361ZZ 197361 reservedUA 198306ZZ 198306 available
UA 197433ZZ 197433 reservedUA 29249ZZ 29249 available
UA 198439ZZ 198439 reservedUA 39333ZZ 39333 available
UA 206424ZZ 206424 reservedUA 39693ZZ 39693 available
UA 210071ZZ 210071 reservedUA 40965ZZ 40965 available
UA 24896ZZ 24896 reservedUA 41158ZZ 41158 available
UA 28926ZZ 28926 reservedUA 41348ZZ 41348 available
UA 31448ZZ 31448 reservedUA 41873ZZ 41873 available
UA 33851ZZ 33851 reservedUA 42502ZZ 42502 available
UA 35406ZZ 35406 reservedUA 44803ZZ 44803 available
UA 42434ZZ 42434 reservedUA 47235ZZ 47235 available
UA 44487ZZ 44487 reservedUA 48280ZZ 48280 available
UA 47600ZZ 47600 reserved
UA 57025ZZ 57025 reserved
UA 60298ZZ 60298 reserved
Table 2 — ASNs that have been moved or registered in Ukraine since 5 February 2022 and are now available to be reassigned.

Figure 2 and Table 3 show the other countries in which the ASNs previously allocated to networks in Ukraine have ended up.

Figure 2 — Where ASNs allocated to Ukraine networks have been transferred since February 2022.
24 February 202219 February 202324 February 202219 February 2023
UA 196741GB 196741UA 34046SC 34046
UA 197335GE 197335UA 34633SK 34633
UA 198109US 198109UA 42564PL 42564
UA 202580SC 202580UA 43123LV 43123
UA 204789GB 204789UA 47517LK 47517
UA 206053BY 206053UA 47752UZ 47752
UA 206439VN 206439UA 48440BG 48440
UA 206447RO 206447UA 49704BG 49704
UA 20724CA 20724UA 50297LT 50297
UA 210119SC 210119UA 50499CA 50499
UA 210132HK 210132UA 51306FR 51306
UA 210138BZ 210138UA 56421EE 56421
UA 212187US 212187UA 58215CZ 58215
UA 212389BE 212389UA 61336SC 61336
UA 25053AT 25053UA 61357NL 61357
UA 25235IL 25235UA 61376LV 61376
UA 28776MT 28776
Table 3 — Where ASNs allocated to Ukraine networks have been transferred since February 2022.

Out of the 33 ASN mentioned above, the following six ASNs were transferred to other entities per the RIPE NCC resource transfer policy:

  • AS196741 LLC “IT HOME” Dataart Solutions Inc. 09/12/2019 POLICY AS196741 DataArt_Technologies UK Ltd LLC “IT HOME” 01/06/2022 POLICY
  • AS197335 Artem Zubkov Freebit LLC 02/11/2022 POLICY
  • AS206447 LLHOST INC. SRL LLHost Inc 13/10/2022 POLICY
  • AS28776 ISV TECH LIMITED SoftServe Ltd. 22/06/2022 POLICY
  • AS34633 Tiramix s.r.o. UKRINDEX LLC 15/02/2023 POLICY
  • AS56421 Eurolir OU LLC “WEECOMI UKRAINE” 27/12/2022 POLICY

IPv4 and IPv6 Address Space

There has been a clear decline in IPv4 address block allocations to Ukraine in the last 12 months (Figure 3). 

Graph showing the number of IPv4 addresses allocated by RIPE NCC to networks in Ukraine since 5 January 2022.
Figure 3 — The number of IPv4 addresses delegated by RIPE NCC to networks in Ukraine (5 January 2022 to 5 February 2022). Source: NRO.

However, just like ASNs, many IPv4 and IPv6 address blocks have been assigned to networks in Ukraine, and many have moved out.

For example, 29 /24 IPv4 blocks (7,424 IPv4 addresses) were allocated by RIPE NCC to networks in Ukraine in the last 12 months.

If we look at the number of IPv6 addresses (Figure 4), we can see a definitive drop—5% in total—in the last 12 months. Of these:

  • Five IPv6 address blocks were returned to RIPE NCC to be reallocated.
  • 33 IPv6 address blocks were either transferred to other networks outside Ukraine or the resource holders changed their country of origin from Ukraine to others countries. Note: all of these were transferred to LVNET Ltd, a service provider based in Cyprus.
Graph showing the number of IPv6 addresses allocated by RIPE NCC to networks in Ukraine since 5 January 2022.
Figure 4 — The number of IPv6 addresses delegated by RIPE NCC to networks in Ukraine (5 January 2022 to 5 February 2022). Source: NRO.

While some networks disappeared from the global routing table, we also witnessed some resilience. For example, on 3 March 2022, AS6712 – FORMAT-TV-AS, based in Mariupol, disappeared from the global routing table (Figure 5). It returned after a month but with only half of the address space that it was using.

Graph showing number of routes from AS6712 that appeared on the global routing table from November 2021 to January 2023.
Figure 5 — Routes from AS6712 that appeared on the global routing table from November 2021 to January 2023. Source: RIPE Stat

Other large networks from the same region, such as AS57864 – MEGABIT and AS35714 – Infoservice-UA, also disappeared around the same time but did not return.

Graph showing number of routes from AS57864 that appeared on the global routing table from November 2021 to January 2023.
Figure 6 — Routes from AS57864 that appeared on the global routing table from November 2021 to January 2023. Source: RIPE Stat.
Graph showing number of routes from AS35714 that appeared on the global routing table from November 2021 to January 2023.
Figure 7 — Routes from AS35714 that appeared on the global routing table from November 2021 to January 2023. Source: RIPE Stat.

Impact on Internet Users

Any network or routes disappearing from the global routing table portrays a grave picture because these are not just networks or IP addresses that are no longer in use. There are people behind the scenes operating and maintaining these networks. And there are people using these IP addresses to connect to the Internet for knowledge, information, and news, and to connect with their loved ones. All of these things become so much more important during times of hardship.

We will continue to monitor and report on these changes and subsequent Internet events, and look into the effect they have on Ukraine and the rest of the world.

Subscribe to the Pulse monthly newsletter to stay up to date.